|
|
Post by Amanda Kimmel on Jan 12, 2011 20:20:56 GMT -5
CRITERIA:
Board basics - easy points - 10 points
-Is there a sign-up board?
-Is there a place to hold challenges?
-Are there confessionals for each player?
-Is there a Tribal Council / Living Room board?
Board design - 20 points
-Does the board look appealing?
-Is there a logo? Does it look nice?
-Do the players have avatars? Do the avatars look nice?
-Are the images (avatars, board pics, flags, etc.) consistent or do they look sloppy?
-Are the colors appealing or do they not mix well?
Concept - 10 points
-Is there a theme or twist?
-Is the theme or twist something fresh or something overused?
-Would YOU want to play in this game?
Cast - 10 points
-Are there at least 20 unique sign-ups?
|
|
|
|
Post by Amanda Kimmel on Jan 12, 2011 21:26:41 GMT -5
LINKS: survs-cahaya4.proboards.com/gelapsurv1.proboards.com/CAHAYA:Board basics - easy points - 10 points10/10 - everything is there. Board design - 20 points12/20 -The board is a bit too red. The avatars are too big and look a little blurry. There is no logo, no memory wall, and no images on the board to take away from the redness. It's just okay overall. Concept - 10 points6/10 - As much as the cartoon idea is interesting, the restricted cast list makes me have much less desire to play. The twist seems somewhat childish with the concept, and this is a good thing since it fits with the theme. It might actually work, and it's obvious that the Hunter will be the first one taken. Cast - 10 points5/10 - Only the ones in the sign-up thread count so I can easily check IPs. 33/50 GELAP:Board basics - easy points - 10 points 10/10 Board design - 20 points 19/20 - The board looks great! Everything looks good, except for a few typographical errors and some of the season one titles being a little too inappropriate. Clearly a lot of effort put into this. Concept - 10 points 8/10 - The idea of completely new castaways is great, and it makes me more interested to play as "Erika Russell" even though I hate her last name (  ). The City vs. Country theme is original, but it restricts the cast somewhat. The original twist of tribe swaps every round would have cost you some points, as it would have destroyed the theme, but in the end the twist is decent. You could have had a second one, like the HIIs for everyone. Also, Swag is on the country tribe? WTF? Austin has like 750k people... and a "gangsta" is clearly a city tribe person. Cast - 10 points10/10 47/50 |
|
|
|
Post by Rob "Boston Rob" Mariano on Jan 12, 2011 21:51:39 GMT -5
Cahaya:
Board Basics - easy points - 10 points:
All of the required things seemed to be there.
10/10
Board Design - 20 points:
I like the avatars that they came up with, however there is a lack of a memory wall as well as a logo, and everyone's usergroup seems to be the same white coloring so I don't see where the admins stand out from the players with that. Everything else is just too much red.
11/20
Concept - 10 points:
I don't think the cast list is a good thing to have, considering people watch a lot of other animated programming outside of the ones they chose. The twist was decent I think.
5/10
Cast - 10 points:
They didn't get their full cast of 20, and a few of them just registered and failed to remove their names from the list.
4/10
Cahaya Total: 30/50
Gelap:
Board basics - easy points - 10 points
Everything is where it should be.
10/10
Board Design - 20 points
I really like their background and the coloring they chose for it. They have really good avatars, a good logo, and a good memory wall as well, I also like the inclusion of prediction writers as well as a voting history and episode chart for their "first season". However, there are a few typos on the castaway bios.
20/20
Concept - 10 points
I really like the whole City vs. Country twist, and I am also glad that the tribe swap after every TC wasn't used cause it kills the city vs. country concept, the cast being all made up people is also appealing . Also, a few of the cast I feel are on the wrong tribes due to their locations.
10/10
Cast - 10 Points
They have their full cast of 20.
10/10
Gelap Total: 50/50
|
|
|
|
Post by Toddy on Jan 12, 2011 22:20:52 GMT -5
Can I just say that Gelap smoked Cahaya on this one? Lol.
|
|
|
|
Post by Amanda Kimmel on Jan 12, 2011 22:22:04 GMT -5
hahaha, Fabio said the same thing. I'll just make it official  |
|
|
|
Post by Sierra Reed on Jan 13, 2011 11:01:35 GMT -5
Sorry I wasn't on last night. I had no internet cause of stupid snow storms... I hate where I live  |
|
|
|
Post by Sierra Reed on Jan 13, 2011 11:03:06 GMT -5
OMG Gelap did WAY better!
|
|
). The City vs. Country theme is original, but it restricts the cast somewhat. The original twist of tribe swaps every round would have cost you some points, as it would have destroyed the theme, but in the end the twist is decent. You could have had a second one, like the HIIs for everyone.
